Quick review for a somewhat lengthy read. I’m actually asking myself in the hours after finishing the book: What on Earth did I just read?
I haven’t read many of Lisa Scottoline’s books, but admittedly it’s been a while and this is the most recent example I can go on. It’s…definitely not the first book I would recommend anyone read from this author. I feel like it was an entertaining read but also a complete waste of time. (That sounds like a contradiction in itself, but I’ll explain shortly.) So much of this book annoyed me to heck and back – mostly for how over the top and non-cohesive it was. The dialogue in some stretches is completely unrealistic and cringe-worthy. I guess the entertaining aspect of it lies in that it plays out like a soap opera – with the main character running to and fro searching for answers that absolutely no one asked, and one calamity building upon another to ramp up the action and conflict to march forcefully through its conclusion. There are times when I like this kind of story if it can poke fun at itself or just proves entertaining to watch with the characters who make the story more than the bones it stands upon. But “Come Home” was the true definition of a false advertisement of a book if I ever started one.
The story centers around Jill, a pediatrician who’s adjusting to life with a new fiance and her daughter. Yet, Abby, Jill’s estranged ex-stepdaughter comes bounding to her doorstep one rainy night to proclaim that her father’s dead and that someone killed him. This sets off a chain of events that lead to Abby’s disappearance, and Jill’s desperate search to find her. Only…the search for Abby takes up a good portion of this story, but it’s just one thread among several microconflicts that don’t really reach satisfying conclusions. “Come Home” dangles false carrots of conflict in front of you, leading you in one direction, but just when you reach a climatic point that promises some answers, the answers lead in another direction that doesn’t really have much to do with the original thread of conflict and seems to get weaker and less intriguing as it goes on. I felt like part of it was Jill’s utter recklessness and stupidity in approaching every mystery around her, and what she finds just happens to hit the mark in some way without really having any kind of payoff.
In retrospect, I really didn’t like most of the characters in this novel, including Jill. I did like Sam and Jill’s friend (mostly because they were the ones who had the most sense), but everyone else was annoying as heck in speaking voice as well as contributing to the microconflicts and unreliable narrators here. I wish I could’ve believed in them or had a good laugh at them, but in the end, the dramatics were lain on far too thick – and the characters far too grating – for me to enjoy this more. I will say it kept me reading and wanting to see what would happen, but I took far too much time on the audiobook and overarching story than the story paid off in the experience. I probably wouldn’t pick up this book again, once was enough.
Overall score: 1.5/5 stars.